UK Web Focus

Innovation and best practices for the Web

Song Of The Week To Accompany The “Blog” Theme

Posted by Brian Kelly on 22 January 2007

Song Of the Week

My song of the week is “100,000 Miles” by June Tabor. This will be available during the week. And this week I’ll be continuing last week’s theme of “blogs” for the content of my postings.

The Sonific Sidebar Widget

Sonific WidgetPuzzled? My continued blog experimentation and discussions continues with a look at another of the sidebar widgets provided in the WordPress.com hosted service -I’ve added the Sonific tool to the blog’s sidebar, as illustrated.

I’ve registered with the Sonific service and chosen a song which can be played using the Sonific widget.

Discussion

Why would one want to add a music-playing widget to a blog’s sidebar? And what are the possible problems and implications in doing this? In particular what are the broader implications which may be relevant to those considering the deployment of a large-scale blogging service? These are some of the issues I’d like to discuss.

From one perspective I could argue that this is my blog, and I can personalise it to reflect my personal preferences, just as I may choose to personalise my desktop with screen savers, etc. And one could argue that a blog which has the voice and opinions of an individual would benefit from allowing readers to gain a better understanding of the personality behind the blog. For many potential blog authors (and we may see a growth in the numbers of authors if institutional blog services start to be deployed more widely) this may be how many regard their blog space (remember the discussions we had about personal home pages during the mid to late 1990s).

On the other hand this blog is intended as a means to inform, discuss and engage with the Web development community. The deployment of widgets which I may like can possibly cause problems for the intended audience of the blog. For example, the Web interface to the blog may be becoming too cluttered and possibly causing usability problems, particularly for browsers with flawed CSS support and the dependencies on Flash to deliver various application services in the sidecar widgets will not be available to browsers which do not support Flash. And who am I to impose my musical preferences on you, dear reader :-)

There are various responses to such concerns. Readers of this blog who use a dedicated RSS reader and view the blog in an aggregated blog will not have such concerns, as they will only see the contents of this posting (plus any embedded objects) but not the widgets on the blog site. So I could argue that if you just want to access the content or the blog, and possibly add your own preferred application environment, then a personalised and customisable RSS reader such as Netvibes or PageFlakes would satisfy your needs. However, as others have pointed out recently, RSS readers still seem to be not widely used. This blog, which is aimed at the Web development community, may be an exception (there does seem to be a high proportion of access to the RSS feeds). However even which such a specialist community, when posting are referenced by others, readers following such links will arrive at the blog Web site.

Ideally the blog would provide the readers with the option to change their display preferences. I have seen this approach taken in a number of blogs (I had some input into developments to the Auricle blog, which enable PDA users to select an interface suitable for viewing on a device with a small screen). I don’t have the options for doing this in the hosted WordPress.com service as I can’t make use of JavaScript. However maybe this is a non-issue if you install WordPress locally – and perhaps other blogging tools provide the end user with the ability to change their display?

The Wider Issues

If you’ve installed WordPress MU (Multi-User) you’ll have a wide range of WordPress plugins you can install, which will then be available for bloggers to select from when they set up a blog on your service. Which widgets should you provide? Should you install every plugin which may be available (or would this be an administrative nightmare and cause problems for your bloggers in trying to identify what they do)? Should you respond to requests from your blogging community? Should you have a policy on plugins which may not be acceptable? But how might this affect legitimate experimentation? Or perhaps we should encourage our community(developers in our institutions, JISC development projects and related development bodies) to engage in development work and we provide access to the services provided by such widgets. Perhaps, reflecting on Sonific’s role in providing access to a sound resource, rather than a widget providing access to a single music track selected by me, a widget which provided access to a variety of Podcasts related to the blogs’ subject area, would be useful?

Returning To My Song Of The Week Experiment

And I thought it was difficult choosing my song of the week (should I go for a fashionable contemporary song, a retro song, a gentle classical piece which may be conducive to reading the blog, a more obscure and pretentious piece – or perhaps something I like!).

However use of the Sonific widget is an experiment, aimed at opening a discussion not just on the use and usability of this particular widget but on the more general issues related to a blog administrator’s provision of widget tools.

Your feedback on the specific and general issues are welcomed.

About these ads

6 Responses to “Song Of The Week To Accompany The “Blog” Theme”

  1. Ian said

    All I am seeing is an error message: “This SongSpot’s uuid is invalid. Please visit Sonific.com to set it up correctly.”

    Browser is Firefox 1.5.

    Ian

  2. Hi Ian. Thanks for the feedback. I’ve checked the Sonific plugin in FireFox 1.5 and IE 7 (on Windows XP platform). It works for me.
    I think you’re raised the issue of the reliability of the various WordPress plugins. And if plugins are to be used seriously (as I’ve suggested they possibly could be) there will be a need for rigourous testing.
    I tried to Google for your error message. I had to remove the apostrophe and found two hits. Following them, however, I found valid music files. So you and the Google indexing robot have hit a problem. Whether this is an intermitent problem or based on a configuration setting of your PC I don’t know (firewalls, etc).
    Any suggestions, anyone?

  3. Greetings everyone, thanks for trying Sonific and testing it! Much appreciated. I will send our CTO to this page to also chime in on the tech issues – so far there are very few that we cannot solve, but of course most of them are within IE ;). WordPress has a pretty good faq on Sonific btw, it’s http://faq.wordpress.com/2006/12/11/using-sonific/
    Also, in terms of Sonific SongSpots discussions, we are running those at http://www.sonificblog.com, and our tags with links to some select examples are at http://www.sonificmusic.com. Thanks again! Cheers Gerd Leonhard, CEO, Sonific LLC

  4. Ian,
    You can reach us directly though feedback@sonific.com if you need help. It’s easier to sort things out that way and then we can post what we learned here and in our help sections. We do add “target sites” and widgets in a rapid pace so sometimes our help texts are less then perfect. Many sites also change and it takes us a few days to notice and adjust things at your end. Your feedback is very valuable to us so please let us know if you got it sorted out or not.
    /Gunnar

  5. Gerd, Gunnar – many thanks for your comments. One of the blog postings I have in my pending tray gives a couple of examples of providers of Web 2.0 services who monitor what the blogging community is saying about their services and engages with the discussions. This is an approach which I would encourage the IT development community within the higher and further education to adopt. So thanks for providing me with this example.

    PS On the subject of Sonific, this week’s song is ‘It’s Not Happening’ by The Be Good Tanyas. I’ve also used a modified theme for the widget.

  6. Note that after over a month of experimenting with the Sonific sidebar widget I have decided to remove this from the sidebar. I will be investigating other WordPress widgets at a later date.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
%d bloggers like this: